Third Place to Relegation in 735 Days !
Note: Article created from Daily Record, Club Statement(s), BBC interviews, Director Comments and departing players...
It took 735 days and just 68 league games for Kilmarnock to go from Europe to a first relegation in three decades.
A dismal 2-1 home defeat to Dundee saw the Ayrshire side crash out of the top flight after 28 years, a first demotion since 1989, having dropped down to the Old Second Division on May 13th 1989 (despite winning 6-0 at Palmerston).
In the space of two years Killie have gone from "Sir" Steve Clarke (as he was affectionately known as) quipping "bye bye Rangers" to a packed Rugby Park to Kyle Lafferty addressing angry fans through a fence in the car park.
When Clarke stood on the Rugby Park pitch on the final day of the 2018-19 season after victory over Rangers he had secured Kilmarnock's highest finish since 1966.
No Club Won More Points Than Killie in 2018!
It's been quite a spectacular fall from grace for a club that looked set to mount an unlikely title challenge in the first half of 2018-19, the first time many fans will have seen their club outside the top flight.
How did Killie go from juggernaut to Hindenberg in such a short space of time? Here are eight factors behind their shambolic relegation.
Though fans chanted for him to stay in emotional scenes after the final whistle the die was already cast.
Clarke had been named Manager of the Year for both Seasons 2017-18 & 2018-19.
That match was on May 19 but the new manager, Angelo Alessio, was not appointed until nearly a month later.
While taking their time to get the right man - and they clearly felt at the time the Italian was the man - in what was the club's most crucial appointment in years is understandable the first Europa League tie was in early July.
Barely a month after that dizzying high momentum had already stalled.
Alessio was an eye-catching appointment on paper and there was justifiable excitement about his arrival.
He'd worked with Antonio Conte at Juventus, Chelsea and the Italian national team, working with some of the best players in the world.
Scottish football can be notoriously resistant to outside ideas though - just look at the mockery Ian Cathro received for having a laptop.
Italian football is notoriously tactical and there was always a risk that players would not be receptive to such a culture shock.
The club looked to ameliorate that by keeping on Clarke's assistant Alex Dyer (right), as well as bringing in Massimo Donati to try and bridge the Scottish-Italian gap.
It soon became clear though that all was not well.
Kirk Broadfoot jumped ship to St Mirren and lamented: "We spent hours just doing shape and him walking us through drills. I know Alessio has worked at some top clubs with top players but I am not sure it was right for the guys we had at Kilmarnock. The majority of the players found it hard and I am not sure how many of them enjoy it."
Angelo Alessio Bounced Out by "Player Power"?
Alessio was gone by December, with captain Gary Dicker later describing his reign as "a shit-show at times".
While Killie had won just one of eight when the Italian left, they sat fifth in the league and he'd been named manager of the month for October.
Senior players insisted there'd been no dressing room unrest, and perhaps Alessio never would have worked out, but when Broadfoot returned in January it left an impression of a dressing room with too much power.
However, the ignominy of the Europa League qualifying exit to Welsh part-timers Connah's Quay never left Alessio.
Stephen O'Donnell, former Kilmarnock defender said: 'It was a complete rip up of a squad built under Steve Clarke. One of my first conversations with him [Alessio] after I came back from international duty was, in broken English, we weren't playing with tactics. When you make bold statements like that then there's going to be unrest."
The biggest sin of all is arguably a complete failure to refresh the team that finished third under Clarke.
Take the team that started that game against Rangers. Greg Taylor, Stephen O'Donnell, Stuart Findlay and Eamonn Brophy have gone and never been adequately replaced.
All had won Full International Cap's while at Killie!
The remaining players are Broadfoot (36), Dicker (34), Alan Power (33), Chris Burke (37) and Rory McKenzie (27). Youssouf Mulumbu (34) was on the books this season but barely featured and went AWOL before the play-offs.
Rory McKenzie (right) in his 10th year was due a testimonial, but nothing was ever organised, in all likelyhood due to the ongoing Covid-19 situation.
Killie had the oldest squad in the Premiership this season and recruitment over the past two years has been woeful.
The likes of Osman Sow, Simeon Jackson, Harvey St Clair, George Oakley and Danny Whitehall haven't solved any attacking issues.
Laurentiu Branescu, Danny Rogers and Colin Doyle have all been tried as replacements for Daniel Bachmann with limited success.
Aaron McGowan, the putative successor O'Donnell has been kept out of the team by Ross Millen, a player who was turning out for Queen's Park before his move to Ayrshire.
Being generous you could perhaps name five signings who have at least been a qualified success before Wright's arrival.
Of those Dario Del Fabro, (right) Niko Hamalainen and Zeno Rossi were loanees. Mitch Pinnock has hardly set the heather alight but did manage four goals and three assists this season, while Nicke Kabamba is limited but has occasionally been effective in the battering ram role.
That's a dismal record in the transfer market and the fact 37-year-old Chris Burke (above) is still the team's main attacking threat speaks volumes.
Billy Bowie smashed it out the park with his appointment of Clarke but things haven't gone well since.
Alessio was gone just 22 games into a three year contract and, whatever the reasons, that's hardly an indication of the right man being picked.
Alex Dyer (right) was popular with players and fans from his time as Clarke's assistant but didn't show much in his caretaker spell.
ng all three games as caretaker, Dyer was confirmed the club's new manager until the end of the campaign, raising further questions about the Ayrshire side's contingency planning.
Kilmarnock would finish the curtailed 2019-20 season in eighth, with Dyer winning only three of his 12 games while recording a points-per-game ratio of just 0.83.
However, the Rugby Park hierarchy saw enough in the 55-year-old to offer him a two-year-deal.
The Englishman failed to register a victory in the first five games of the 2020-21 season, but a run of three successive wins throughout September and October had them sitting fifth after 10 games.
But just three victories in the following 15 league fixtures led the Kilmarnock board to remove their manager from his position in February with the club in ninth - four points above the relegation play-off spot.
Alex Dyer left Killie, with the worst points-per-game record of any Killie manager since their return to the top flight.
Though not many would have a bad word to say about the Englishman as a man, as a manager his limitations were evident and he was arguably given too long this term.
At the Seasons End Cathy Jamieson Said: "He (Tommy Wright) came in a bit too late".
Tommy Wright was a good choice to replace him on paper and had overseen an upturn in form, but two dismal play-off performances and the fact he couldn't stave off relegation means that many Killie fans have a "jury is still out" verdict.
The club were in 10th position when he took over in February - four points clear of Hamilton Academical at the foot of the table.
It took until his fourth game to gain a point - against Dundee United at home - and a further two games to secure his first win - an emphatic 4-1 victory over Motherwell.
That dragged Wright's men off the bottom of the table and offered hope for the Kilmarnock faithful - but it was shortlived as just two league wins followed.
Bowie has put plenty of his own money into the club and can't be accused of not backing his managers, but mistakes have been made in terms of appointments.
The problems with recruitment have been detailed but those issues haven't arisen in a vaccum.
Alessio came from a culture where a the manager works under a sporting director and had no experience of the Scottish game.
Despite that no sporting director was appointed for the summer window, a likely reason for the hodge-podge of signings from Italy and the Scottish lower leagues.
In November of 2019 James Fowler (right) was appointed as 'head of football operations' with the brief of being "responsible for all club recruitment and scouting".
A club legend, the former midfielder had no experience in the role and was soon working above a new manager in Dyer.
If we're to take his role at face value then the poor recruitment falls on his shoulders and Fowler's record has to be questioned.
In theory such a role should see the club plan coherently for the future despite whoever is in the dugout but little in the the way of long-term development has been obvious.
The summer saw a pursuit of Daniel Bachmann thwarted by Watford's relegation and whether Rogers was always Plan B or was a panic signing the goalkeeper did not impress at all.
Attempting to address that problem by loaning Doyle from relegated Hearts did not help, with both responsible for some absolute real howlers. Jake Eastwood was originally "tagged" as the starter, but the Sunderland loanee, was injured on opening day, after giving up a howler himself.
A lack of imagination has also been evident.
Having tried and failed to get in contact with Mulumbu in January 2020, Fowler did bring the Congolese back for this season.
After a year out of the game the midfielder could never get 100% fit and he packed up and left after the final game of the regular season, sharing a "tit for tat" spat with Tommy Wright, as he headed out the door.
Aaron Tshibola, (a former five million quid's worth at Aston Villa) another Clarke era player, was also brought back and even Bachmann - who would have been a good signing - is a previous loanee.
Tommy Wright's only signing, Kyle Lafferty, (left) was clearly a success,and he (and not Fowler) should take the plaudits on this signing.
Did Dyer do the same on players like Pinnock, Brandon Haunstrup and Whitehall recruited from the English lower leagues? And, if so, what is Fowler doing in his role?
Rodgers (left) & Doyle (right) Each Dropped After Each Conceding Three Goals at Home to the Buddies
There's no question that success under Clarke was built on a solid defence.
It would be unfair to characterise his Killie team as purely defensive, with the likes of Brophy, Jones, Mulumbu and Greg Stewart providing plenty going forward.
Famous wins over Celtic and Rangers were built on being hard to beat though and that's not something you could say about Killie in Season 2020-21.
Their 43 goals this season is actually the fourth best in the Premiership but shipping 54 doomed the Ayrshire side to the play-offs.
They twice drew 3-3 with St Mirren in the run-in, (incuding conceding a 119th min extra time penalty in the Cup) and the dropping of 5 out of 6 points to the Staggies, while conceding 5 goals, was to prove destructive to Killie's survival hopes.
Many Late Errors Cost Killie Dearly!
Needing to score four goals to win a game is not sustainable and the numbers are damning.
Killie conceded just 31 goals in Clarke's final season, and while Alessio was criticised for boring football his side were hard to beat.
The Italian managed eight clean sheets in his 17 league games in charge, and Kilmarnock have kept six in the 18 months since.
Tommy Wright Laments: "Too many players haven't turned up and not just in the play-off games – it's all season. That's 24 defeats this season in 40 games if you count this as two league games in. That says a lot about the squad. We've been gifting goals away. The first day I arrived I told them if they do the basics, defend well and take responsibility you can stay in the league. But we haven't done that".
It's hard to win games when you're constantly shipping goals and even harder when you're playing a man down.
Killie received a mammoth six red cards this season, the highest of any team in the league.
Given they were consigned to the play-offs by two points, it's not unreasonable to say that without daft sendings off a disastrous season could merely have been a poor one.
After Livingston’s late winner on Boxing Day it was now five defeats in a row for Killie and eight losses in nine league games. Alex Dyer responded to the defeat by saying he would have no complaints if the club’s board decided his time was up.
Dyer Said: "If Billy [Bowie, Kilmarnock chairman] says tomorrow 'that's time' I'll shake his hand and give him a hug because they've been good to me".
Many Killie fans were expecting Dyer to be binned..... Unfortunately Killie's next Club Press Release was....
“Kilmarnock Football Club utterly condemns a letter which was delivered to the club this morning containing racist abuse directed at our manager, Alex Dyer. We are working with Police Scotland to identify any individuals involved in this disgusting act and we will pursue the strongest possible action we can against them. Racism in any form is completely unacceptable and must be called out whenever and wherever it is found. As a club, we have shown our support to rid the game and society as a whole of racial discrimination by taking the knee before each fixture this season and we will continue to do so.”
In hindsight it was pretty obvious that Dyer knew his time was up, however the Club chose to stand behind him, in light of the racist abuse he had just received.
Killie did the honorable thing, however Dyer's sacking was inevitable, and came "a bit to late" (Cathy Jamieson, May 2021). Tommy Wright ended up with no transfer window to work with, and two dud keepers into the bargain.
One can certainly argue, that the higly unfortunate racist letter (aimed at Alex Dyer) that the club received, prolonged Dyer's tenure, leaving a replacement manager with no transfer window to work with.
No good deed goes unpunished ..... Right? Forum thread on this issue - HERE
Happier Days for Cathy Jamison, Billy Bowie & Phyllis McLeish
Director Cathy Jamieson: "Simply isn't good enough. It's really important that we have confidence in the manager. He knows what he wants to do, he's got a vision for the way forward and as a board we need to back him. He came in a bit too late, but we do have the right manager now. We can rebuild and we will rebuild."
Director Phyllis McLeish: "The club has been looking down the barrel of the gun for more than just a few weeks. We were going to stick with the player budget we've got, there wouldn't be a reduction. We wanted to give Tommy and the team he's going to rebuild over the summer every possible chance to make it a very brief sojourn in the Championship."
Director Billy Bowie: "It's been a tough season for us all to get through, but we're going to bounce back. We've haemorrhaged a lot of money to keep the club going but we're still going to keep it going."
Kris Boyd on SKY (on the Eve of the Dee Home game): "There will be one almighty clear-out in the summer and, with maybe two or three exceptions, it is hard to make a case for most of the current squad staying at the club. Unfortunately the story of Kilmarnock’s season, is that defensively they have not been good enough and that was the case long before the current manager arrived. Their away form this term has also been absolutely abysmal. I have watched them a number of times over the past nine months and they have been poor. But Thursday topped the lot. It was Dundee who looked like the Premiership team and played with an arrogance and swagger. Killie were diabolical, especially at the back, while the current goalkeeping situation doesn’t help either. Both Colin Doyle and Danny Rogers have made high-profile errors this season.
That doesn’t help the defenders in front of them. When you have confidence in your goalkeeper, it helps your own game. You can get tighter to strikers and not worry about them running in behind. However, there is a real nervousness about the Kilmarnock team and it all starts from the keeper. Wright keeps chopping and changing and that tells me he doesn’t trust either of them. The uncertainty then filters through the team and you can see that in most games".
Club Manager Tommy Wright: "I just feel sorry for the fans. I've let them down and ultimately the players have let themselves and let the club down. But I'll take my responsibility myself as well. I'm not ducking anything. I thought I could get us out of it, but unfortunately I didn't.” - MORE
Club Captain Gary Dicker: Complete departing comments can be found - HERE.
You can share your thoughts/opinions ... On Where It All Went Wrong for Killie - HERE
Our policy relating to data collection and privacy has fairness at its heart and is never intended to cause objection or complaint and to that end if there is any dubiety we will not store your information. As a business we wish to stay in communication with your and keep you up to date with news, offers and updates on our product which you may find of interest, but we will only do this with your clear and specific consent.
KILLIE FC is committed to ensuring that your privacy is protected. Should we ask you to provide certain information by which you can be identified when using this website, then you can be assured that it will only be used in accordance with this privacy statement.
KILLIE FC may change this policy from time to time by updating this page. You should check this page from time to time to ensure that you are happy with any changes. This policy is effective from 13th Jun 2018
We are committed to ensuring that your information is secure. To prevent unauthorised access or disclosure, we have put in place suitable physical, electronic and managerial procedures to safeguard and secure the information we collect online and offline.
Where we collect this information
As a business we collect data for a number of sources, but our data policy applies to all of the following including personal data collected at reception, check in, exhibitions, on and off-line competitions, guest questionnaires, online bookings, online communications, digital newsletter sign ups from websites and social media, shared promotions with partners and others not listed.
We confirm that unless specific consent is given by the user the information shared will not be stored beyond the purpose intended. If specific consent is given to use the information collected it will be stored securely and digitally encrypted and password protected.
A cookie is a small file which asks permission to be placed on your computer's hard drive. Once you agree, the file is added and the cookie helps analyse web traffic or lets you know when you visit a particular site. Cookies allow web applications to respond to you as an individual. The web application can tailor its operations to your needs, likes and dislikes by gathering and remembering information about your preferences.
We use traffic log cookies to identify which pages are being used. This helps us analyse data, using Google Analytics normally but on occasion other aggregation tools that advise us about web page traffic and improve our website in order to tailor it to customer needs. We only use this information for statistical analysis purposes and then the data is removed from the system.
Overall, cookies help us provide you with a better website, by enabling us to monitor which pages you find useful and which you do not. A cookie in no way gives us access to your computer or any information about you, other than the data you choose to share with us.
You can choose to accept or decline cookies. Most web browsers automatically accept cookies, but you can usually modify your browser setting to decline cookies if you prefer. This may prevent you from taking full advantage of the website.
Links to other websites
Our website may contain links to other websites of interest. However, once you have used these links to leave our site, you should note that we do not have any control over that other website. Therefore, we cannot be responsible for the protection and privacy of any information which you provide whilst visiting such sites and such sites are not governed by this privacy statement. You should exercise caution and look at the privacy statement applicable to the website in question.
Controlling your personal information
You may choose to restrict the collection or use of your personal information in the following ways:
Ã¢âÂ whenever you are asked to fill in a form on the website, look for the box that you can click to indicate that you do not want the information to be used by anybody for direct marketing purposes
Ã¢âÂ if you have previously agreed to us using your personal information for direct marketing purposes, you may change your mind at any time by writing to or emailing us or by clicking unsubscribe where available.
We will not sell, distribute or lease your personal information to third parties unless we have your permission or are required by law to do so. We may use your personal information to send you promotional information about third parties which we think you may find interesting only if you specifically consent to us that you wish this to happen.
We undertake that third parties will only include businesses that support our business and your stay such as travel providers, visitor attractions, event providers and others directly related to our business offering.
If you believe that any information we are holding on you is incorrect or incomplete, please write to or email us [email protected] as soon as possible, at the above address. We will promptly correct any information found to be incorrect.
Our Website and In House Data Collection Policy
Our email collection policy is fully consent based and in entering your details clear consent is given by the user to receive future marketing materials from ourselves. The following information makes clear our policy on use of consent based email marketing and communications.
What we collect
We may collect the following information on a consent only basis:
Ã¢âÂ name and job title
Ã¢âÂ contact information including email address
Ã¢âÂ demographic information such as postcode, preferences and interests
Ã¢âÂ other information relevant to customer surveys and/or offers
What we do with the information we gather
The majority of the information we gather is required for contractual and legal purposes and to allow us to offer products and services as purchased.
When consent is given to use the information for marketing and communication purposes it is used for the following reasons:
Ã¢âÂ We may periodically send promotional emails about new products, special offers or other information which we think you may find interesting using the email address which you have provided.
Ã¢âÂ From time to time, we may also use your information to contact you using your provided email address for market research purposes.
Your information will never be shared with any third parties and at all times you have the right to unsubscribe permanently from our database with a simple click of the unsubscribe information at which time your details will be deleted from the mailing lists and removed from the database permanently with no archived records retained.
Your use of the Killie FC Web Site is subject to these terms and by using the Site you show your agreement to such terms. If you do not accept our terms, please do not use the Web Site.
This Web Site belongs to Killie FC.
Headings used in these terms and conditions are for convenience only and shall not affect their interpretation.
The images, logos and names on this Web Site which identify Killie FC or third parties and their products and services are proprietary marks of Killie FC and/or the relevant third parties. Nothing contained in this Web Site shall be deemed to confer on any person any license or right on the part of Killie FC or any third party with respect to any such image, logo or name.
Killie FC reserves the right, at any time and without prior notice, to remove or cease to supply any product or service contained on this Web Site. In the event that such removal takes place we shall not be liable to you in any way whatsoever for such removal.
Telephone calls using the telephone numbers provided on this Web Site and email correspondence with Killie FC at the email addresses accessible through, or discernible from, this Web Site may be recorded or monitored. By using such communication methods you are consenting to the recording or monitoring of the same.
The price of calls may vary depending on your telecoms supplier. Please check with your operator for exact charges.
This Web Site is for non-commercial, personal use only. The services contained on this Web Site may be supplied on a commercial basis on payment to Killie FC or its service or product suppliers of its charges from time to time. Please contact us on Email: [email protected]
In the event that you use any of the services contained on this Web Site for commercial use, Killie FC shall be entitled to charge you at its applicable rates in respect of such commercial use.
The copyright in the material contained in this Web Site belongs to Killie FC or its licensed source. Any person may copy any part of this material, subject to the following conditions:
the material may not be used for commercial purposes;
the copies must retain any copyrights or other intellectual property notices contained in the original material;
the products and technology or processes described in this Web Site may be subject to other intellectual property rights reserved by Killie FC or by other third parties with no license granted in respect of those intellectual property rights); images on this Web Site are protected by copyright as its text by IPR and may not be reproduced or appropriated in any manner without the written permission of their respective owner(s).
We reserve the right to change these terms and conditions at any time by posting changes on the Web Site. It is your responsibility to review the Web Site terms and conditions to ensure you are aware of the latest terms and conditions. Your use of this Web Site after a change has been posted will be deemed to signify your acceptance of the modified terms and conditions. We recommend that you print off and retain for your records a copy of these terms and conditions from time to time and a copy of any terms and conditions relating to any product or service which you apply for online, together with any related application form completed and submitted.
Any amendment to terms and conditions must be agreed in writing by us, or, if appropriate, by the relevant company or individual supplier with whom you contract.
Whilst Killie FC has taken due care and attention in the preparation of the contents of this Web Site, this Web Site and the information, names, images, pictures, logos, icons regarding or relating to Killie FC or our products and services marketed on the site (or to third party products and services), are provided on an 'as is' basis without any representation or endorsement being made and without any warranty of any kind, whether express or implied, including but not limited to, any implied warranties of satisfactory quality, fitness for a particular purpose, non-infringement, compatibility, security and accuracy.
To the extent permitted by law, all such terms and warranties are hereby excluded. In no event will Killie FC be liable, whether in contract or tort (including negligence or breach of statutory duty) or otherwise for any losses sustained and arising out of or in connection with use of this Web Site including, without limitation, loss of profits, loss of data or loss of goodwill (in all these cases whether direct or indirect) nor any indirect, economic, consequential or special loss.
Killie FC does not represent that the information contained in this Web Site is accurate, comprehensive, verified or complete, and shall accept no liability for the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this Web Site or for any reliance placed by any person on the information.
Killie FC does not warrant that the functions or materials accessible from or contained in this Web Site will be uninterrupted or error free, that defects will be corrected or that this Web Site or the server that makes it available are virus or bug free or represent the full functionality, accuracy, reliability of the materials.
If any of these Terms and Conditions (or any terms and conditions relating to a product or service referred to in this Web Site) should be determined to be illegal, invalid or otherwise unenforceable by reason of the laws of any state or country in which such terms and conditions are intended to be effective, then to the extent of such illegality, invalidity or unenforceability, and in relation to such state or country only, such terms or condition shall be deleted and severed from the rest of the relevant terms and conditions and the remaining terms and conditions shall survive, remain in full force and effect and continue to be binding and enforceable. Nothing in these terms and conditions shall exclude Killie FC's liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence of Killie FC.
All Intellectual Property Rights (including, without limitation, all database rights, rights in designs, rights in know-how, patents and rights in inventions (in all cases whether registered or unregistered and including all rights to apply for registration) and all other intellectual or industrial property rights in any jurisdiction) in any information, content, materials, data or processes contained in or to this Web Site belong to Killie FC or its licensed source. All rights of Killie FC in such Intellectual Property Rights are hereby reserved.
Killie FC makes no representation that any product or service referred to on or through the Web Site is appropriate for use, or available in other locations. The information and other materials contained in this Web Site may not satisfy the laws of any other country and those who choose to access this Site from other locations are responsible for compliance with local laws if and to the extent local laws are applicable.
These Terms and Conditions and any terms and conditions relating to products or services described in this Web Site shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the law of Scotland. Disputes arising in relation to the same shall, unless otherwise expressly agreed, be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of Scotland.
Certain (hypertext) links, advertisements or suppliers promotion will lead you to Web Sites that are not under the control of Killie FC. When you activate any of these links, you will leave Killie FC Web Site by opening a new window and we have no control over and will accept no responsibility or liability in respect of the material on any such other Web Site. By allowing links with third party Web Sites Killie FC does not intend to solicit business or offer any security to any person in any country, directly or indirectly.
Every effort will be made to carry out the contract but its due performance is subject to cancellation by Killie FC or to such variation as we may find necessary as a result of inability to secure labour, materials or supplies or as a result of any act of God, War, Strike, Lockout or other labour dispute, Fire, Flood, Drought, Legislation, or other cause (whether of the foregoing class or not) beyond the sellers control.
We have tried to make this website as accessible as possible and easy to use for everyone, regardless of circumstance or ability.
All our page templates comply with the WCAG Priority 2 checkpoints as a minimum requirement. And we make every effort to ensure that all the content on our site meets this standard too. We are making every effort to ensure that we don't exclude any users. For example:
We try to publish all our text content as accessible HTML rather than in other formats such as PDF. Where we do publish PDFs or other formats our policy is to make them as accessible as we can.